By Legum Pacific Editorial ·
Suppose a landlord asks rent for years after a tenant leaves
Imagine you own a shop or a flat that was wrongly occupied by a tenant after the tenancy ended. You go to court to get back the premises and also to claim money for the time the tenant kept using your property. That money is called mesne profits (compensation for use-and-occupation). This case shows how courts pick the rate and interest when occupation continued for many years.
What does the law say?
Mesne profits are compensatory. They aim to make the owner whole for loss caused by wrongful occupation. There is no fixed formula. Courts look at the property’s nature and location, the prevailing rental value, the evidence produced by both sides, and the circumstances of the case. A decree for possession can be final while the exact mesne-profits amount is decided later by a separate inquiry under Order XX Rule 12 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). That happened here.
What did the Supreme Court decide?
Case: Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) Through Lrs. v. M/s Goodyear India Ltd., C.A. No. 9668-9669/2013, 2026 INSC 1240.
The original suit began in 1990. The trial court granted possession to the owners in 1998 but left mesne profits to be fixed later. The trial court assessed mesne profits at Rs.22 and Rs.11 per sq ft per month for ground and mezzanine areas. The first appellate court set aside that finding and proceeded on the basis of the admitted rent rate for determining mesne profits. The Delhi High Court then re-examined the matter. It noticed an admission by the tenant’s own witness that prevailing rents in the locality at the relevant time ranged between Rs.5 and Rs.8 per sq ft per month. Taking the record as a whole, the High Court fixed mesne profits at Rs.7 per sq ft per month (ground) and Rs.5 per sq ft per month (mezzanine). The High Court directed simple interest at 7.5% per annum from the months the mesne profits became payable and stated that payment of the decretal amount within two months would reduce the interest to 6% per annum.
The Supreme Court examined the evidence and the legal approach. It said mesne profits assessments are fact-based and not driven by any rigid rule. The Supreme Court found that the High Court had rightly considered the tenant’s admission about local rents and had made a balanced assessment. The Supreme Court also held that interest is an integral component of mesne profits and that the High Court’s interest direction was reasonable in the circumstances. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals.
What does this mean for ordinary people and businesses?
- If you are a landlord seeking compensation for use after a tenancy ended, courts will expect evidence about market rents and comparables. Admissions in the record can be important.
- If you are a tenant who remained in possession after termination, the court can order payment of mesne profits plus interest to compensate the owner for loss of use.
- Courts will aim for a fair estimate based on the record rather than a fixed mathematical rule. A rate within the evidential range is likely to be upheld.
- Long delays in litigation do not prevent a court from assessing mesne profits on the available evidence and bringing finality to the dispute.
Key points
- Mesne profits compensate the owner for wrongful occupation; assessment depends on facts, not a formula.
- In this case the High Court fixed Rs.7/sq ft (ground) and Rs.5/sq ft (mezzanine) per month.
- The High Court ordered simple interest at 7.5% p.a., reduced to 6% p.a. if the decretal amount was paid within two months.
- The High Court relied on an admission by the tenant’s witness about prevailing local rents when fixing the rates.
- The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals and affirmed the High Court’s factual assessment.
Source: Supreme Court of India (official judgment) (opens in a new tab) · Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) Through Lrs. v. M/s Goodyear India Ltd., C.A. No. 9668-9669/2013, 2026 INSC 1240